Skip to content

SEO & AI Optimization

BigCommerce vs Shopify: Which Platform Is Better for SEO?

BigCommerce and Shopify are both hosted ecommerce platforms, so neither one will rank a store on its own. What they decide is how much control you have over the parts of SEO that live in the platform: URLs, redirects, duplicate pages, speed and structured data. This guide compares BigCommerce vs Shopify on those points, so you can see which one fits the way your store is built and how you plan to grow it.

Where the platform matters for SEO, and where it does not

Most of what moves rankings for an online store is the same on both platforms: product and category pages that answer what shoppers search for, original product descriptions, good photos, reviews, internal links between related products, and links from other sites. A weak store stays weak on either platform.

The platform matters for the technical layer underneath. That is where BigCommerce and Shopify make different choices.

URL structure

Shopify uses fixed URL prefixes. Products live under /products/, categories (collections) under /collections/, content pages under /pages/ and blog posts under /blogs/. You can change the last part of each URL, but not the prefix. For most stores this is fine; it mainly matters when you migrate from another platform and want to keep old URLs exactly as they were.

BigCommerce lets you change the URL structure for products, categories, brands and pages in its settings, including short URLs without a fixed folder. That flexibility helps during migrations and for stores that want category paths in their product URLs.

Duplicate pages and canonical tags

On Shopify, a product can be reached through more than one path, for example /collections/shoes/products/runner and /products/runner. Shopify themes add a canonical tag that points to the /products/ version, so search engines know which one to index. The issue to check is your theme’s internal links: some themes link to the collection-based path, which spreads crawling across duplicate URLs.

BigCommerce also outputs canonical tags. Faceted navigation (filtering by size, color or price) is where both platforms need care, because filters can create many URL variations. Check that filtered pages are not being indexed in bulk.

Redirects, robots.txt and sitemaps

  • Redirects: both platforms support 301 redirects from the admin, and both can create a redirect automatically when you change a product URL. Check that the option is on before you rename products.
  • Robots.txt: both generate a robots.txt file. Shopify lets you edit it through a theme template (robots.txt.liquid); BigCommerce lets you edit it in the store settings.
  • XML sitemaps: both create and update a sitemap automatically. Submit it in Google Search Console.

Site speed

Both platforms run on fast hosting with a content delivery network and include SSL. In practice, speed problems on either platform usually come from the theme, large images and apps or scripts added over time. On Shopify, every app that adds code to the storefront is worth questioning; on BigCommerce, the same applies to third-party scripts and heavy themes. Measure product and category pages on a phone, not just the home page.

Structured data

Product structured data (price, availability, reviews) helps Google show richer product results. Many current themes on both platforms include basic product markup. Review markup and more detailed fields often come from a reviews app or a custom edit. Test a product page with Google’s Rich Results Test before and after any theme change.

Built-in features versus apps

BigCommerce includes more ecommerce features in the core platform, such as product filtering and multiple storefront options on some plans. Shopify keeps the core lean and relies on its large app store for extra features. Neither approach is better for SEO by itself, but every app adds code and cost, so a store that needs many features may end up lighter on BigCommerce, and a store that needs few may be simpler on Shopify.

Which one to choose

  • Choose Shopify if you want the simplest setup, the largest choice of themes and apps, and you are comfortable with fixed URL prefixes.
  • Choose BigCommerce if you need control over URL structure, have a large catalog with complex filtering, or are migrating a store and want to keep its existing URLs.
  • Either way, the result depends more on product content, category pages, internal links and site speed than on the platform name.

Moving from one platform to the other

Most SEO losses during a platform switch come from missing redirects. Before you move, export every product, category and content URL, map each one to its new address, and set up 301 redirects before launch. Then watch Google Search Console for 404 errors and drops in indexed pages during the first weeks.

If you are planning a new store or a move between platforms, our Shopify and e-commerce design team can map the redirects and set up the technical SEO before launch. For a side-by-side look at Shopify alone, read Shopify advantages and drawbacks.

Keep reading